Every Inside

Get All Your Home Improvement Solutions with Our Handy Tips

How to Coordinate New Tile With Old Tile : Only 5 Steps

How to Coordinate New Tile With Old Tile

Last Updated on October 29, 2022

Coordinating new tiles with old tiles can be a headache. In order to properly match a new tile with an old one, you need to consider color, pattern, and size. It’s usually best to use a similar style or color.

If you wish to create a unique design, coordinating tiles can provide an excellent opportunity to do so. No matter what route you choose, always consider the overall effect you are trying to achieve.

For attractive and long-lasting results, you need to understand how to coordinate new tile with old tile so that your home renovation project will succeed. This article will teach you the basics of tile coordination so that you can have a beautiful home.

How to Coordinate New Tile With Old Tile: A Step-By-Step Guide

ceramic tile

When it comes to coordinating new tile with old tile, it can be a tricky design challenge.  If you’re not careful, you can end up with a space that looks mismatched and unappealing. The key to avoiding this is to take your time and plan ahead.

If you have decided to install a new tile but are unsure of how to coordinate the new tile with the old tile, this step-by-step guide will help you achieve the perfect results.

1. Start by Assessing the Existing Tile

To coordinate a new tile that will complement the existing tile, you must first look closely at the old tile. Assessing the overall color scheme of your space.

If your old tile is a neutral color, you’ll have more flexibility in terms of choosing a new tile. Be careful not to select a tile that is too similar in color to your old tile, as this can create an unattractive look if your old tile is bold.

2. Select a New Tile That Complements the Old Tile

Once you understand the existing tile, it will be easier for you to find a complementary tile for it. When you coordinate a new tile, it is important to consider both the color and the style.

A good rule of thumb is to choose a tile that is either similar to the old tile or a complementary color. You should also consider the style of your space as a whole.

A simple, clean design is ideal for a modern space. If your space is more traditional, it might be best to choose a tile that has an intricate design. You will be able to create a more cohesive look in your room this way.

3. Pay Attention to the Size of Your Old Tile

Your old tile’s size should be taken into consideration. In the event that your old tile is a small size, it may be advisable to replace it with a similar size. This seamless transition will be very easy to coordinate a new tile.

If your old tile is large, you may want to replace it with a tile of a different size. This will give your home a more updated look and help you achieve the desired aesthetic for your space. 

Because the size of your tile can greatly impact the overall look of your space, it is important to select a new tile that is the right size for your home. Therefore, do not be afraid to experiment with different sizes.

4. Think About the Overall Shape

The shape of your old tile can greatly influence the appearance of your new tile. Depending on whether your old tile is square or rectangle, you’ll likely wish to choose a similar tile that is also a square or rectangle. You will then have a cohesive look with your new tiles. 

When your old tile has an irregular shape, you may want to choose a new tile that is a different shape to add visual interest. For example, a round tile in a square room can add a whimsy touch. 

A tile’s shape should ultimately be determined by the style you wish to achieve. This will ensure that your new tile looks coordinated and perfect.

5. Pattern Is Also Important

Aside from the shape, the pattern on your old tile can also impact the look of your new tile. Your old tile may have a busy pattern, so you may want to choose a tile with a more muted design instead.

This will help to create a sense of visual balance in your space. If your old tile has a very simple pattern, you may want to select a new tile with a more intricate pattern. This will add visual depth and interest to the room.

Again, the decision of what pattern to choose for your new tile should be based on your personal style and the overall look you’re trying to achieve. So, take some time to experiment and find the perfect pattern for your space.

How Do You Find the Exact Tile?

white subway tile

When replacing tiles, you should ensure that they can match well with the existing ones. But, it can be a challenge if you don’t have any extra tiles or you can’t remember where you got the tile from.

In this case, you’ll need to do a bit of investigative work to find the exact match. To begin, examine the existing floor tile carefully. Take note of the size, shape, color, and any other distinctive features. To help you later, take a photo of the tile.

Next, head to your local home improvement store or search online for tile retailers. Show the staff your photo and describe what you’re looking for. With any luck, they’ll be able to help you track down the exact tile that you need.

Be prepared to order a small quantity, as it’s unlikely that they’ll have an entire box of the same tile in stock. If you’re trying to match a tile that’s no longer in production, you may need to purchase a sheet of similar-looking tiles and then cut them down to size.

Tips for Matching New Tile With Old Tile

Here  are a few tips to keep in mind when matching a new tile with an old tile:

  • To find the closest match in color, pattern, and texture, bring a sample of your old tile to your local hardware store or tile retailer.
  • When choosing a new tile, keep the overall style of your space in mind. Traditional designs and colors work well if you want a traditional look.
  • Try mixing and matching different shapes, sizes, and textures for a more contemporary look.
  • If the tiles don’t quite match, consider using grout to create a visual break between the old and new tiles. Alternatively, you could use trim or molding to create a physical boundary between the two types of tile. 
  • Remember that imperfections can add character and charm to your space. Create a unique look for your home by embracing any slight differences in your tile.

How do you choose tile combinations?

hexagon tile

There are a few things to consider when choosing tile combinations. First, consider your space’s style as a whole. Choosing tiles that are similar in color and pattern is a good way to achieve a more traditional look.

Combine different shapes, sizes, and textures to create a more contemporary look. After that, think about what the space is for. If you’re tiling a backsplash or shower, you’ll want to choose waterproof materials that are easy to clean.

For tile flooring, durability and slip resistance are key. Then, don’t forget about your aesthetic. Select tile combinations that reflect your personal style and make you happy every time you see them. With these guidelines in mind, you’re sure to create a tile combination you love.

Making Coordinate Tiles Work for You

Coordinate tiles can be a great way to add some interest to your home decor. Whether you use them as accent pieces or create a whole coordinate-tile mural, these versatile tiles can add a touch of personality to any room. Coordinate tiles can be made to work for you by following these tips:

  1. Choose a color scheme that complements your existing décor. Coordinate tiles are available in a wide range of colors, so it’s easy to find a scheme that works with your preexisting décor.
  1. Use different sizes and shapes of coordinate tiles to create visual interest. Coordinate tiles come in a variety of shapes and sizes, so mix and match them to create an interesting design.
  1. Make sure that you creatively place your tiles. Instead of simply lining them up in rows, try creating patterns or groupings with your coordinate tiles.
  1. It is possible to create contrasting patterns and colors by using grout. By using different colors of grout, you can create a whole new look with your coordinate tiles.

Is It Ok to Mix Matte and Glossy Tiles?

backsplash tile

A common question we get at our tile store is whether it is okay to mix glossy and matte tiles. The answer is yes. This look is quite common and can be a beautiful yet quiet way to add texture to your spaces.

Matte tiles have a softer, more matt finish resulting in muted colors and a velvety surface, while glossy tiles have a shinier surface and tend to reflect light more. Combining these two finishes can help create depth and dimension in any room.

When mixing tile finishes, you should consider the overall aesthetic you are trying to achieve. If you want a more natural look, you might pair matte wood-look tiles with glossy stone-look tiles.

Alternatively, if you want a more modern space, mixing different colored matte and glossy glass tiles can create a beautiful backsplash or accent wall.

How to Ensure the New Tile Matches the Old?

If you’re trying to match a new tile to an old tile, the best place to start is by taking samples of your old tile to a tile shop or hardware store. This will help ensure that you find a close match in color, texture, and pattern.

When choosing a new tile, it’s also essential to consider your space’s overall design. If you’re going for a more traditional look, choose tiles with similar colors and patterns. This will create a sense of visual continuity in your space.

A contemporary look can be achieved by combining and contrasting materials, shapes, and textures. This will add interest and depth to your space. A cohesive and polished look is ensured by finding the perfect match for old tile.

Should All Bathroom Tiles Match?

If you’re leaning towards matching tiles, try to find a set that includes both tile floor and wall tile. This will create a cohesive look throughout the bathroom. There are pros and cons to both approaches. A clean and elegant bathroom tile can be achieved by matching tiles.

But on the other hand, combining different types of tiles can bring personality and visual interest to the space. Ultimately, the decision comes down to personal preference and the appearance of the bathroom.

If you decide to mix and match, be sure to choose tiles that complement each other in terms of color, pattern, and texture. This will help tie the different elements together and create a unified look.

What to Do When the Tiles Don’t Match?

There is no need to despair if you find yourself in a situation where the tiles don’t quite correspond. You can do a few things to make the tile work in your space. 

Using grout between old and new tiles can create a visual break. This will help to camouflage any differences in color or pattern. Trim or molding can also be used to distinguish between two tiles.

This is a great way to blend the tiles together without making them identical. No matter what you do, don’t forget that imperfections have their own charm and character. Create a unique look with your tile by embracing slight differences.


Coordinated tiles can add a lot of visual interest to your home. You can create an impressive look with complementary color and shape tiles. Combining old and new tiles can add personality and whimsy to your space.

Now that you know how to coordinate new tile with old tile, it’s time to get started on your project. Use these tips to create a cohesive and stylish look for your home. With a little bit of planning, you can achieve professional-looking results that are sure to impress.

Relevant Article To Read:

How to Coordinate New Tile With Old Tile : Only 5 Steps

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to top